Review / Ygtaani — the duchy whose borders walk
mcp proposal · package #87
Ygtaani — the duchy whose borders walk
Grounded on the western-cluster canon entities (countries_and_continents.continents.silgolt.nations.kokit.duchy_of_kokit, ...nasun.nasun_ground, ...hihn.hihn_confluence, canon_json) for cluster voice, adjacency conventions and the Nasun archiving/truce-calendar mechanism. Spatial grounding from map/spatial: Ygtaani provinces Lareth, Marauthazma; adjacency to Aalhotikyn, Hihn, Kokit, Namuzdus, Nasun, Ohynso, Revakgol, Siltuz, Súzyngol, Tovo, Tuzraag, Maduwez. Seasonal-pastoral framing consistent with Silgolt biome data (savanna and tropical seasonal forest) in countries_and_continents.continents.silgolt.
Canonized
2/2
items resolved
Proposal workspace — not canon. Accepting an item records your
review decision. Writing it into canon requires a separate exact preview and
typed confirmation. Overview items are never imported.
Review the whole package · 1 items
Item
Full package
Timeline
Relationships
Canon impact
History
Export .md
Export .json
Mechanical consistency
Canon impact Targets and conflicts are derived without a model call. Overview items are omitted — they never touch canon.
Kind Entity Target countries_and_continents.continents.silgolt.nations.ygtaani.duchy_of_ygtaani
✓ No mechanical conflict detected
Selected item
Package overview
Accepted
Overview v2
Overview frames this package for review. It is never written to canon.
Decision note
Accept
Request revision
Reject
Return to review
Manual revision
Title
Text# Ask
Ygtaani appears throughout the western cluster's spatial adjacency and in no canon text. This package writes it as a cluster sibling built on the one geographic fact the cluster hasn't yet used: **Silgolt's savanna runs on a wet and dry season**, and somebody in this landscape must be moving herds.
## The thesis
Ygtaani is a transhumant duchy, and its institution is **the Drove-right** — a set of grazing corridors that cross other countries' sovereign territory by ancient right. Ygtaani law travels with the herds. Inside a drove corridor, on the move, in season, a Ygtaani herd is under Ygtaani jurisdiction even when it is standing in Aalhotikyn.
That makes Ygtaani the one country in the cluster whose borders are not a line but a calendar, and it makes the duchy a permanent low-grade legal problem for everyone it walks through. It also gives the cluster something it currently lacks: a member whose sovereignty is contested not because it is weak, but because its claim is genuinely strange.
The Drove-right is written to hang off Nasun's existing truce calendar — the fair-months during which regional hostilities are suspended by common custom — which is canon, and which the droves depend on absolutely.
## Items
1. **`country` entity — The Duchy of Ygtaani.** The Drove-right, the Horn-Court that rides with the herds, the winter parliament, and the standing friction of a jurisdiction that moves through other people's fields.
## Open questions for the human reviewer
- **Naming — resolved, and it turned up something else.** An earlier version of this package flagged `Kaetijul` vs `Kaetijulhel` as a canon inconsistency. It is not one: `-jul` is simply the short form of `-julhel`, so both are correct and the country files just use the long form. This package uses the long form to match its siblings. The real gap the investigation surfaced is that **Yukejulhel has no species entity at all** — unlike Medesjul, Kaetijul, Jaajul, and Aedhelirjul, it is a Julhel branch named across four canon country files with nothing behind it. That deserves its own package.
- The Drove-right implies the other cluster states have conceded extraterritorial jurisdiction, which is a significant thing to have written into their character retroactively. If that's too strong, the fallback is a weaker version — corridors as easement only, with disputes going to Nasun rather than to Ygtaani's own court.
- I've tied the droves to Nasun's canon truce calendar. If the fair-months were meant to be purely a market/oath device rather than a movement season, this connection should be cut.
- Ygtaani's adjacency includes Revakgol. I've written the eastern droves as having been abandoned within living memory rather than giving the duchy an active imperial frontier, since Ohynso and Tovo already carry that role.
What changed?
Save as new pending version
AI action · one call
ActionRevise this item
PersonalityCaeru Vane · Character Spark Dajun Kess · Caravan Practicalist Elin Varr · Lore Conversation Partner Finaanaa Riiulgruth · Abyssal Muse Ilthara Saelun · Ritual-Risk Reader Kaemeih Kehtuz · Critic Lethra Vaun · Identity Witness Maerin Keth · Route Scout Mirola Vek · Myth-Teller Moyaakog/Sigtaara Peltuz · Scribe Nalya Vireth · Landscape Witness Serrin Daal · Place-Maker Silyuhn / Rîwɔk · Lore Master Suurak Vuldren · Imperial Archivist Tethunaas Peltuz · Scribe Vessa Rookwake · Rumor-Broker Ykhe/Yaat Peltuz · Scribe
ProviderOpenRouter (free models) · free · unavailable Claude — CLI (subscription) · subscription quota Codex — CLI (subscription) · subscription quota Grok — CLI (subscription) · subscription quota Kimi — CLI (subscription) · subscription quota xAI — API key (per-token) · paid (xAI key) · unavailable Z.ai — GLM Coding Plan · subscription quota Aion Labs — API key (free quota) · free quota Mistral — API key (free quota) · free quota
Model
Instruction
Preview one-call gate
Overview accepted as read. Nothing to canonize.